Richvc wrote:
I am very much in favor of creativity but I do remember a time when great photos were achieved before Photoshop.
I agree with you, I too remember a time when great photos were achieved long before Photoshop.
However (caution old man rant coming)
Many of these images were post processed in the darkroom. I'm not sure why Photoshop evokes such a visceral reaction, considering photographic masters have been manipulating photos for a long time 100+ years. You could certainly say "now it is easy and anybody can do it" and that would be a misinformed argument. it's true that in this age of the Internet we get to see all of the "bad Photoshop" images along with the good ones. But let's not discount the good ones. The real difference is we now get to see all the poorly done images, and before digital, these images would never make it out of the photographer's basement.
So here is what makes the sad about this topic.
In 1981, 16 years old, I worked two jobs every day after school and on weekends. All so I could afford the darkroom set up I wanted. I could hardly wait for my special order Beseler XL large format enlarger. I spent hours in the darkroom, practicing until the chemicals made my fingers dry and cracked. I would use specific film, paper, and chemicals to get a desired look. Using colored filters on black and white paper to increase or decrease contrast. Dodging and burning, stacking negatives, shooting through transparencies, and indexing the print so it could be exposed multiple times. By the time I got into college, this skill set was considered good. In fact it was considered a big deal if you are really good in the darkroom. You could get a good paying job just doing retouching/printing (This is still true today). Now, some will look down on a person who is really good at post (Photoshop, Lightroom, Capture 1, DXO, whatever). It doesn't matter if they have spent hundreds of hours studying and honing their skills. And that is just sad.
To be clear, pressing a button to apply a filter, is not a skill. I believe these skills became bad when the internet allowed us to see the sh*t that should have never made it out of the basement. These skills only became bad when the internet (TV and some print publications) allowed people to distort reality so they could sell us something. HOPEFULLY fewer people will us it to "sell us something". Then those retouchers with skill will get there due.
http://fstoppers.com/business/photoshop-bad-business-nsfw-45163